Site Logo
  • About
    • Executive Committee
    • Member organisations
    • Advocacy Action 1971 – 1999
    • Timeline
    • Volunteer
  • Who we help
    • Smoking in Australia
      • Tobacco free future
    • Indigenous Australians
    • Pregnant and New Mothers
    • People experiencing Mental Illness
    • LGBTI People
    • People in correctional facilities
    • Other priority groups
  • What we do
    • Smoke free housing
      • Changing the law
    • Smoke free zones
      • Shopping centres
      • Health facilities
      • Sporting clubs
      • Perth Airport
    • WA Aboriginal Tobacco Control Strategic Leadership Team
    • Bob Elphick Award
      • 2017 Bob Elphick Award
    • Tobacco free investments
    • National Tobacco Control Scoreboard
      • Scoreboard history
    • Smoking prevention among youth
    • Smoking and mental health
    • Success stories
      • Crown Casino
      • Outdoor dining areas
      • Smoke free cars
      • Bars/Clubs
      • Unite 2 Innovate
      • Feet First – Aboriginal Tobacco Control Project
  • What you can do
    • Quit smoking today
    • Make your house smoke free
    • Involve Your School In Critics' Choice
    • Stop government and super fund investment in tobacco
    • Community success stories
    • Share your project
  • Resources
    • ACOSH resources
    • Compelling reasons for health professionals to support smokers to quit
    • Big Tobacco
      • Industry watch
      • Say what? Actual ‘Big Tobacco’ quotes
    • World No Tobacco Day
    • Organisations working in tobacco control
  • Law and policy
    • 10-Point Plan for a Tobacco-Free WA by 2030
    • Australian tobacco control legislation
      • Australian best practice
      • Graphic health warnings
      • Electronic cigarettes
    • WA tobacco control legislation
      • Priorities for WA Local Governments
      • Tobacco legislation and policy timeline
    • World law and policy
  • News
    • Latest news
    • Global news
    • Media releases
    • Wall of Shame
    • Wall of Fame
  • Donate
  • Contact

News

Home » 30th anniversary of Australian legal ruling on second-hand smoke

30th anniversary of Australian legal ruling on second-hand smoke

ACOSH · Feb 04, 2021 · Media releases

MEDIA RELEASE

Thirty years ago, working in an office where people smoked, eating at a café where people smoked at the next table and being surrounded by people smoking at the footy was common.

In Australia, all this changed after Federal Court Justice Trevor Morling handed down a judgment on 7 Feb 1991, finding that second-hand smoke causes lung cancer in non-smokers and asthma attacks, as well as respiratory disease in children.

The case was the Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc (AFCO) versus the Tobacco Institute of Australia Limited (TIA).

“The decision was the first of its kind by a superior court anywhere in the world” noted Professor Peter Le Souëf (Professor of Paediatrics, University of Western Australia).

“The success of this collaboration between medical experts and lawyers to counteract the efforts of the tobacco industry to deny scientific evidence was one of the most important milestones in the history of reducing rates of smoking” said Professor Le Souëf.

Professor Le Souëf was the first witness in the court case providing expert testimony on the damage to children’s health from exposure to second-hand smoke. The 30th anniversary of the decision is acknowledged this week in an essay in the UK medical journal The Lancet written by Neil Francey who acted as Counsel for AFCO throughout the legal proceedings.

The litigation arose from TIA publishing an advertisement in major Australian newspapers on 1 July 1986 making the claim that “there is little evidence and nothing which proves scientifically that cigarette smoking causes disease in non-smokers”.

The timing of the tobacco industry advertisement was an attempt to undermine the 1986 report on passive smoking by the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) in Australia.

Other international reviews of the evidence on second-hand smoke from 1985 to 1988[i] built on landmark studies published in 1981[ii] which found that exposure to second-hand smoke is a cause of lung cancer in non-smokers.

“We’re not yet living in a smoke-free environment in 2021, despite the overwhelming evidence on the dangers of second-hand smoke” said Professor Le Souëf. “Opportunities remain to realise the many benefits of smoke-free policies in areas such as beer gardens in licenced premises, crowded outdoor areas, government-supported housing and multi-unit residences”. [iii]

– ENDS –

Media Enquiries: Professor Peter Le Souëf  ph 0419 915 795  peter.lesouef@uwa.edu.au

Comments from former AFCO CEO Mr Robin Brown:

“Why did I, as CEO of under-resourced AFCO, push its board to agree to take on the tobacco industry?  Many in the consumer movement thought it a pretty crazy enterprise with little chance of success, a wasteful diversion of resources from our core business and that it clearly risked the end of the organisation.  Their view was reasonable, but some of us saw the potential upside of changing public policy on tobacco and saving lives in Australia and beyond as worth it.

“Why was AFCO the actor in this?  Why not the specialist organisations like Action on Smoking and Health and the Heart Foundation?  Well, they didn’t have a focus on consumer law and didn’t see that it could be used in this way.  Of course as soon as we got going they were fully engaged  collaborators.

We did have a secondary motive – to push the national consumer protection agency to “be a better consumer protector – it had lapsed badly under the chairmanship of Bob McComas (Chairman WD and HO Wills Holdings from 1992-1996). As well as the main outcome of boosting government tobacco regulation the case proved the importance of private rights of action in consumer and other legislation and of effective citizen organisations in keeping statutory regulators up to the mark. AFCO really only kicked off this project.  It would have got nowhere without the huge contributions of Neil Francey and the other lawyers and health specialist witnesses.”

 

[i] International Agency for Research on Cancer Monographs on the Evaluation of the Carcinogenic Risk to Humans: Volume 38 Tobacco Smoking. 1985

US Department of Health and Human Services’ The Health Consequences of Involuntary Smoking: A Report of the Surgeon General. 1986

National Research Council Committee on Passive Smoking’s Environmental Tobacco Smoke: Measuring Exposures and Assessing Health Effects. 1986

UK Fourth Report of the Independent Scientific Committee on Smoking and Health. 1988

[ii] Trichopoulos D. Lung cancer and passive smoking. Int. J. Cancer. 1981; Hirayama T. Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher risk of lung cancer: A study from japan. British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Ed.), 1981

[iii] Brooks A, Buchanan T, Oakes W. Smoke-free environments: current status and remaining challenges in Australia. Public Health Res Pract. 2020;30(3):e3032022.

 

60

SHARES
facebook Share on Facebook
Twitter Tweet
Follow Follow us
custom Share
custom Share
custom Share
custom Share
custom Share

Related News

Political parties should commit to phasing out the sale of cigarettes in Australia by 2030

Political parties should commit to phasing out the sale of cigarettes in Australia by 2030

Jan 29, 2021
Australia needs to expand smoke-free areas

Australia needs to expand smoke-free areas

Jan 20, 2021
Major award recognises leadership in WA tobacco control

Major award recognises leadership in WA tobacco control

Dec 04, 2020
Health groups call on Crown Perth to make casino entirely smoke-free

Health groups call on Crown Perth to make casino entirely smoke-free

Nov 27, 2020
Review of the evidence says e-cigarettes not the answer for Australian smokers

Review of the evidence says e-cigarettes not the answer for Australian smokers

Sep 30, 2020
Growing evidence of harms highlight the need for science, not bogus health claims, to inform Australia’s policy on e-cigarettes

Growing evidence of harms highlight the need for science, not bogus health claims, to inform Australia’s policy on e-cigarettes

Sep 18, 2020

Smoking isn't social, but we are.
Add your voice to the conversation.

  • Like us
  • Follow us

Subscribe today to receive all the latest Acosh E-News

If you need help to make your community smoke free, call us on (08) 6365 5436

Supported By Acosh Logo
  • Accessibility
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Sitemap

© 2021 ACOSH AUSTRALIAN COUNCIL ON SMOKING AND HEALTH | ABN 20 902 420 947
BRANDING AGENCY JUICEBOX